Most Mass Shooters Are Not Mentally Ill | Carmela Epright | TEDxGreenville

  • Yayınlanma Tarihi:  2 yıl önce
  • Carmela Epright is a bioethicist who advocates for resources for mental illness while dispelling myths about the profiles of mass shooters. Carmela Epright is a Professor of Philosophy at Furman University and a Clinical Professor of Neuropsychiatry and Behavioral Sciences at the University of South Carolina School of Medicine. She has served as a visiting scholar to the Medical University of South Carolina, The University of South Carolina Medical School’s Center for Bioethics and Medical Humanities and to the Institute for Applied Ethics at Dartmouth College. Dr. Epright received her M.A. and Ph.D. degrees in philosophy and an M.A. in Applied Ethics from Loyola University, Chicago. In 2004 she was awarded the Alester G. Furman, Jr. and Janie Earle Furman Award for Meritorious Teaching at Furman University. This talk was given at a TEDx event using the TED conference format but independently organized by a local community. Learn more at http://ted.com/tedx
  • Video Süresi: 00:11:55
  • TEDxTalks English United States Life Crime Criminal justice Fear Mental health 

Yorum Sayısı: 308

  • Life of a Bibliophile
    Life of a Bibliophile 4 saat önce

    To say she's ill-informed is an understatement. Mass shootings and mental health go hand in hand. However, unstable mental health is not the only reason why mass shootings happen. Poor gun control, inactivity from the US government, uneducated people on mental health in seats of power, people who care about guns more than children, etc.

  • slayne2
    slayne2 1 gün önce

    To conflate mental illness with insanity is a grave mistake. Mass murderers are not normal. This woman is pushing to control “sane” people with guns. That’s you and me.

  • Wilky _
    Wilky _ 2 gün önce

    Today I Learned, toxic masculinity and pepe the frog are to blame for mass shootings :)

  • Tracer2376
    Tracer2376 3 gün önce

    Wow, she is wrong in many areas of phycological profiling. But if you look at all the mass shooters to date, Local Law Enforcement to the F.B.I was called on them do to threats in the past each one had a phycological eval which also proved they should not be near firearms. From social media accounts looked at, to show that all of them should have not been near or around a firearm and were under psychological evaluation as of current state. She must be leftists considering she is wrong as the rest of them.

    Carmela Epright has no idea what she is speaking about on this issue. She is just as nuts as they are.

    @1:51 England like the United States? Ummmm not really sweetheart your meds are calling. Did you not read the history of red coats, Paul Revier, ummmm hello Buller, Buller... I will leave it at that.


    As for mass shooters, each one had a Px for a high amount of antidepressants, or anxiety medication ect... that is a public fact. You name it they all have had a pill prescribed to them, from a therapist stating that they need to be on this medication. And when they get off the medication or refuse to take it, that will lead to another situation. Which can lead to a mass shooting?

  • scott- o
    scott- o 3 gün önce

    You do realize that she's analyzing crisis actors, don't you?

  • Bhanu Vikram
    Bhanu Vikram 3 gün önce

    Most mass shooters were on psych drugs that list homicidal ideation as a "side" effect.

  • Amy Peacemaker
    Amy Peacemaker 6 gün önce

    What about psychotropic drugs?

  • john smith
    john smith 6 gün önce

    I see what she is saying but she needs to go look up the word PSYCHOPATH, and read carefully what it means and it is in fact a form of serious mental illness

  • Treading on the Snake
    Treading on the Snake 6 gün önce

    This wave of mass shootings started after Huawei's 5g technology was implemented throughout the USA. 5G technology causes multiple health disasters, one of which is to interfere with healthy function of the brain. This is an attack by China's Huawei tech company. The massively powerful cell towers can be used to magnify DEW and do cause fires.

  • Richard Gusmanov
    Richard Gusmanov 6 gün önce

    The only thing I agree with is that we should not blame people for having mental illness because it would be like blaming people for having a disease such as cancer.

  • multimossad
    multimossad 6 gün önce

    What about MK Ultra ? nobody mentions that mental programing proyect created by the US government.

  • D Allen
    D Allen 1 hafta önce

    Incredibly informative and mind opening. Thanks for posting.

  • Chris Hein
    Chris Hein 1 hafta önce

    10:04 lol

  • Lisa Merrill
    Lisa Merrill 1 hafta önce

    She's also wrong about Beta Males Many are attractive to women. They are our creatives usually more gentle, sweet, not controlling, they are not MACHO Alphas. I am more attracted to Beta males. Don't care for ego bound Alphas!

  • Prescription side effect fighter

    It's the prescription drugs

  • Vallyrah
    Vallyrah 1 hafta önce

    The legal definition of mental illness doesn't match DSM's definition. The legal definition is designed to allow those who are ill to be locked up.

  • Ash G
    Ash G 1 hafta önce

    Psychopathology is subjective anyway and to be honest it mostly just refers to behaviours and cognition that are not normative in the culture that you are a member of. Because they aren't normative, people with them struggle to function in society. But at the same time the fact that the U.S. has a crazy amount of gun violence can be seen as a culture bound syndrome, in which case everybody within that culture has some form of psychopathology (relative to wider western culture).

    Personally I do look at mass shooters as having a mental illness (by definition of their shooting), because that behaviour is so far removed from normative behaviour in western culture (although not as far removed in U.S. culture). But that's just my subjective opinion..

  • mellow 5.56
    mellow 5.56 1 hafta önce

    Lady you are mentally ill

  • Meesh
    Meesh 1 hafta önce

    Mass killers are the end result of the social changes that have occurred in the last hundred years which have turned men into buffoons in the eyes of society, in my opinion.

  • Meesh
    Meesh 1 hafta önce

    She is right. The problem is not MENTAL illness, but SPIRITUAL illness.

  • Meesh
    Meesh 1 hafta önce

    Does this mean that mass killers are mentally healthy?

  • Sean Hilla
    Sean Hilla 2 hafta önce

    This went from serious to a joke, then to a meme. Praise beta cuck pepe!!!! REEEEEEEEEEEEEEE

  • markysharky03
    markysharky03 2 hafta önce

    Uh oh Pepe and the incels on 4chan are the real problem

  • CRasch Net
    CRasch Net 2 hafta önce

    Not wanting to kill massive number of people is not mentally ill? Are you insane?

  • Simone Ipesports
    Simone Ipesports 2 hafta önce

    Worst ted talk ever

  • Diane Stallworthy
    Diane Stallworthy 2 hafta önce

    Why does her voice shake?

  • Yuanyuan H
    Yuanyuan H 3 hafta önce

    When is the world finally going to study priscribed and or abused priscribed medications to answer the following question: In criminal cases of violence was the suspect consuming priscribed medications x amount of time before the crime and if so what medications where consumed. Than make the results of the study fully public.

  • PartiallySane
    PartiallySane 3 hafta önce

    As a person dealing with mental illness, I admit that I've had homicidal thoughts along with suicidal thoughts. There are many factors to take into account when it comes to becoming a mass shooter, but I believe that mental illness is critical to people to even think about killing others. Under the influence of mental illness, if you allow yourself, you can deteriorate as a person to the point that you lose the value of your own life. Eventually you might start blaming society for your problems and thus start developing homicidal thoughts/ideation to the point that you might start planning to kill others and in worst cases, go through with said plan. You don't just wake up one day and say "Yup, I'm going to kill people today". No, you slowly degrade mentally until the point at which you've either lost contact with reality or have a very distorted version of it. I'm speaking form personal experience. Mass killers use murder as a way to enact revenge on others (and to regain control in their life, because that's something that they lacked before the committed the act), because in their mind even innocent people have contributed to their misery. I.e. they blame people for being happy and for not talking to them or dating them (a toxic and distorted mindset).They kill them because they have a mindset like this "I want to kill myself but I won't let society win, so I'll take some people down with me"(This doesn't apply to all mass shooters, for example Nikolas Cruz didn't try to commit suicide and tried to run away, but I think it was more of an act out of fear and panic and he might be regretting not killing himself now, knowing what awaits him in prison.). Most people that commit mass murder are mentally ill, but most mentally ill aren't mass killers. I agree that there are some exceptions in which shooters are not mentally ill, but that's like a small fraction of most mass murderers.

  • Mark Anthony
    Mark Anthony 3 hafta önce

    Mental illness isn't just having obsessions or seeing bugs. Conduct and personality disorders are still a viable possibility. Yes, the vast majority of mentally ill people are not a danger to others, there are still aspects of violence that can be attributed to certain disorders.

  • kicks
    kicks 1 ay önce

    So...she's saying...most people who commit mass shootings are mentally healthy? Because last I checked, Ill was the opposite of healthy, so if she's saying they're not mentally ill, she must be claiming they were healthy. How on earth did she reach that conclusion? I think it's "doctors" like this who are the reason we can't solve the problem.

  • When the donut Is half priced

    I’m guessing to her this applies to everyone but white people

  • Marcos Hernandez
    Marcos Hernandez 1 ay önce

    James Huberty called a mental clinic on July 17, 1984, He was brushed off by the operator. I don't really know what her point is?

  • JanCarol11
    JanCarol11 1 ay önce

    and lordy, she stigmatizes the "crazy" as much as she does the shooters. Voice hearers are threatening as they talk to "invisible friends," and the homeless are "delusional" even though they've lost everything. If I lost everything, I wouldn't behave to social norms, either.

  • BellyBro
    BellyBro 1 ay önce

    Believe it or not buying a gun and killing someone isn't just a normal person type of thing

  • WrongHandedGuitarist

    Apparently they just let anyone be doctors these days... I agree with the comment that this is the worst TED talk I have ever seen.

    Webster defines mental illness as "any of a broad range of medical conditions (such as major depression, schizophrenia, obsessive compulsive disorder, or panic disorder) that are marked primarily by sufficient disorganization of personality, mind, or emotions to impair normal psychological functioning and cause marked distress or disability and that are typically associated with a disruption in normal thinking, feeling, mood, behavior, interpersonal interactions, or daily functioning."

    The person being prescribed Clonazepam for social anxiety may not exhibit any violent or destructive behavior but they are by definition not mentally fit. A person walking into a classroom with a shotgun to destroy the lives of his classmates is also by definition not mentally fit. I don't think anybody is actually saying mass shooters aren't to be held accountable because of mental illness, nor is anybody actually saying that all mentally ill people are mass shooters in the making. Not all mentally ill persons are or exhibit violent behaviors, but all mass shooters are in fact mentally ill. It's an actual fact supported by decades of research.

    Also, do some research on Eric Harris before you spread falsehoods. Seriously, it is embarassing for a doctor of any kind to deliberately omit factual information to further an agenda like this. Eric Harris was meeting with a therapist with some regularity and was prescribed both Zoloft and later Luvox to help with his depression, mood swings and OCD that he was diagnosed with. Other examples like Adam Lanza, Randy Stair, Seung-hui Cho and so on all have varying conditions that fall under the blanket term of mental illness as well.

  • Mago Rose
    Mago Rose 1 ay önce

    How about you get some facts?

    Are you going to tell me someone who actively chooses and plans to murder kids and strangers is sane?

    Show me your alternative facts and you’ll have me. I thought TED talks were supposed to be intelligent, not just emotionally charged nonsensical opinion.

  • Matthew Treeby
    Matthew Treeby 1 ay önce

    But mental Illnes or not take away access to firearms then none of these atrocities would happen!!

  • Ashley Nave
    Ashley Nave 1 ay önce

    I have only a mild degree of Bipolar Depression, PTSD/Social Anxieties, and ADD/ADHD with borderline intellectual functionality/general learning disabilities. People with mental illnesses are misunderstood, and they are not serious threat to society. I live in the country, not in most places where mass shootings occurred. The government government and organizations behind stero typing the mentally ill causes people to be discriminated and treated wrongly.

  • KSGV
    KSGV 2 ay önce

    Well, shes pretty much wrong on all levels. Klebold was definitely mentally ill, she doesn't really know much about the "betas" or more accurately, the "Incels (involuntary celibate)" and clearly bought into the front of what 4chan seems to be.

  • kicks
    kicks 2 ay önce

    This Ted Talk is bad and you should feel bad